I have a problem with Emily Lane (Sarah Drew). I like her. I really do. But three seasons into Mistletoe Murders, I’m beginning to wonder how much longer Detective Sam Wilner (Peter Mooney) is supposed to put up with this woman’s bullshit.

The chemistry between them is undeniable, and I’ve been rooting for these two since they first met. But Emily has a nasty habit of promising honesty while keeping enough secrets to fill Santa’s entire workshop.

And poor Sam keeps falling for her.

Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Episode 1, “Don’t Fear the Wreather – Part 1,” brings Emily back to Fletcher’s Grove after an eleven-month absence, introduces a woman suspected of murdering multiple husbands, and reminds us that nobody in this town can investigate a crime without the local Christmas shop owner getting involved.

It’s cheesy. It’s ridiculous. And I still can’t look away.

Emily Lane, You Naughty Girl

The season picks up where the Season 2 finale left us, with Emily’s old partner Aaron (Aaron Ashmore) standing at her door and delivering alarming news about Chimera, the hacking organization connected to her former life.

Members of the group are being targeted, and Emily could be next.

Considering what we’ve already learned about her past, I can’t blame Emily for being frightened. She’s spent years trying to escape the life she once lived as Grace Barlow, and Aaron turning up in Fletcher’s Grove is hardly a welcome Christmas surprise.

But what does she do when Sam arrives? She lies. AGAIN.

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

And that’s what really gets me. Emily has promised Sam she’d stop lying to him more than once. She made that promise again before Aaron appeared, just as their relationship seemed to be moving toward something built on actual trust.

Yes, Sam knows Emily isn’t who she originally claimed to be. He knows her real name is Grace Barlow, and she’s admitted to working in intelligence.

But Sam hasn’t heard the whole story about Chimera, Aaron, or Emily’s involvement with the CIA. We learned considerably more through the Season 2 finale’s flashbacks than Sam did from Emily herself. When she tried to tell him there was more, he interrupted her.

So he’s not fully informed about the danger Aaron represents or the circumstances that led Emily into that world. And rather than finally explain everything, Emily disappears for eleven months.

What really irritates me is that Sam isn’t the only person she hurts. There’s also his daughter Violet (Sierra Marilyn Riley), who genuinely cares about Emily.

When Emily finally returns, Sam discovers she’s back because he happens to drive past her reopened Christmas shop. Seriously, lady? You couldn’t make a phone call?

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

The guy is investigating a murder, yet the sight of Emily’s shop being open is enough to stop him in his tracks. That’s how much he cares about her. It’s also such a ridiculously Hallmark moment that I couldn’t help laughing.

Sam has already looked into Emily’s past, accepted the truths she’s shared, and made it clear he wants her in his life. Maybe he’d be more understanding than she thinks if she stopped feeding him edited versions of the truth.

Instead, Emily admits she’s going to keep lying because she doesn’t want to hurt him. How the hell is that supposed to work?

And despite all of this, I still want them together. That’s what makes Mistletoe Murders so aggravatingly enjoyable.

Another Christmas, Another Murder, Another Amateur Detective

Meanwhile, Fletcher’s Grove has a new murder to solve.

Richard Smiley, a man who apparently never encountered a Christmas decoration he didn’t want to hang on his house, has been killed. His widow, Helen (Catherine Bell), is a local wreath maker with a rather unfortunate history involving dead husbands.

And because this is Hallmark, she might as well have a flashing neon sign over her head reading SUSPECT.

Between the suspicious mittens, the accusations from her former stepson Wes, and the rather alarming nickname “The Grim Wreather,” Helen looks like the obvious culprit.Too obvious, if you ask me.

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

I don’t believe she murdered Richard, and I’m not convinced she killed her previous husbands, either. Her explanations for those deaths might sound convenient, but an unfortunate marital track record doesn’t automatically make someone a killer.

Catherine Bell is a great addition to the episode, playing a woman whose past has become an invitation for practically everybody to assume the worst about her.

And that gives Emily something in common with Helen. Both women are being judged by things that happened before the people around them knew them.

Of course, Emily might want to remember that understanding somebody else’s complicated past doesn’t excuse lying about your own.

The investigation also brings out one of my favorite ridiculous Hallmark traditions: women who somehow become indispensable to police investigations despite not actually being police officers.

Jennifer Shannon does it. Hannah Banana does it. And Emily has practically turned it into a second career.

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

Sam doesn’t merely tolerate her interference. He actually invites her along to help question Helen because he thinks she’ll make the suspect more comfortable.

What the hell is happening at this police station?

Within minutes, Emily is back in the middle of another murder case, and nobody seems particularly concerned that the local gift-shop owner is doing half the detective work.

Sam really needs to get his head out of Emily’s ass and do some investigating himself.

But let’s face it. If the cops solved everything without these women, half the Hallmark mystery lineup wouldn’t exist.

And I say that as somebody who never expected to become a Hallmark fan, much less binge two seasons of Mistletoe Murders to get ready for the third.

Is the Grim Wreather Really a Killer?

I have my suspicions, and Helen isn’t at the top of the list.

Wes is awfully determined to convince everybody that his former stepmother is a murderer. His accusations are serious, but his campaign against her also makes me wonder how much of his story we’re supposed to believe.

Could he be responsible for Richard’s death himself? Could the supposed Christmas apology note be another piece of manipulation?

And why isn’t Sam asking more questions about how Wes learned of the murder?

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

The mayor is another possibility. He’s far too interested in getting Sam to stop investigating, even approaching Emily about it. That strikes me as suspicious, particularly if there’s some personal connection to Helen we haven’t discovered.

Of course, I could be completely wrong about both of them. That’s part of the fun.

The episode gives us just enough to question Helen’s guilt without offering a convincing alternative. And when she’s discovered inside neighbor Albert’s house after he reports an intruder, things certainly don’t look good for her.

But I still don’t buy it.

There’s something almost comical about the idea that a woman with multiple dead husbands would murder another one while leaving an increasingly obvious trail of evidence.

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

Maybe she’s genuinely dangerous. Maybe she’s spectacularly unlucky. Either way, I’m interested in seeing how the mystery plays out.

And I appreciate that the show doesn’t forget Fletcher’s Grove’s other residents. Brooke (Kylee Evans) is already eyeing Richard’s Christmas Cheerman position while the poor man’s body is still warm, and Violet and June want Emily to take the job.

Everybody is delighted to have Emily back, including Sue (Jean Yoon), which only makes me wonder why Emily is so determined to keep one foot out the door.

The Biggest Mystery Is Still Emily

As entertaining as the Smiley murder is, Emily’s history remains the more compelling mystery.

The Season 2 finale revealed that Grace Barlow had been involved with Chimera and that her cooperation with federal authorities led to the CIA recruiting her to help catch Aaron.

Now Aaron has returned with news that at least two former Chimera members have been murdered. Emily checks his story, realizes the threat is real, and takes off. But who’s targeting the group, and what does any of this mean for her?

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

Sam certainly doesn’t know the whole story, and neither do we.

What exactly was Emily doing during the eleven months she was away from Fletcher’s Grove?

If Aaron’s warning was serious enough to send her running, why has she returned to the very town where Sam and Violet could become targets?

There’s clearly much more to her past than being a talented hacker who fell in with the wrong people. And the possibility that her intelligence work extended beyond what we’ve already seen raises even more questions.

While I love watching Emily and Sam together, their relationship can’t survive indefinitely on chemistry and half-truths.

Episodic still from Mistletoe Murders S3E1: "Don’t Fear the Wreather - Part 1"
©2026 Hallmark Media

Sam has given Emily chance after chance to trust him. He’s accepted truths that would have sent plenty of people running, and he’s never stopped caring about her. Yet every time Emily promises to stop lying, another secret emerges.

At some point, she has to decide whether she trusts him enough to tell him the whole damn story.

In the meantime, she deserves a great big lump of coal in her Christmas stocking.

Although I’ll give her this: the woman still has fabulous hair.

🔥 Our Verdict: WATCHABLE

Mistletoe Murders is a Hallmark mystery, people. It’s going to be cheesy. The police are going to make questionable decisions. An amateur detective is going to insert herself into an investigation, and somebody will probably find time for romance while there’s a dead body nearby.

That doesn’t mean it isn’t entertaining.

Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney remain the reason I enjoy this series so much. Their chemistry makes Emily and Sam easy to root for, even when Emily is behaving like an absolute pain in the ass.

Catherine Bell also makes an intriguing addition as Helen Smiley, whose suspicious history gives the murder investigation plenty to work with.

And the show has found a good balance between its latest murder mystery and the larger questions surrounding Emily’s past.

I don’t think Helen killed Richard. My money is still on Wes or the mayor, although Helen’s unexpected appearance in Albert’s house has certainly complicated matters.

But the mystery I’m most interested in solving is Emily herself. She has a man who loves her, a teenager who adores her, and an entire town happy to welcome her home.

For somebody who’s spent so long looking for a place to belong, she seems awfully determined to sabotage the one she’s found.

I’m glad Mistletoe Murders is back. Even if Emily Lane is going to drive me absolutely f*cking nuts this Christmas.

Oh, and I have to give the writers credit for turning Blue Öyster Cult’s “(Don’t Fear) The Reaper” into “Don’t Fear the Wreather.” That title alone gave me a good laugh.


Read All of Our Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Coverage

More Hallmark Coverage:

Keep checking back as we add more Hallmark movies and shows to our watch rotation. Maybe even Hannah Banana


Leave A Reply