The sweetest moment in Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Episode 2, “Don’t Fear the Wreather – Part 2,” comes during the debate between Emily and Brooke for Christmas Cheerman.
Brooke is onstage promising voters she’ll deliver the Christmas market everyone’s wanted for years by this Christmas. When it’s Emily’s turn, she uses her time to explain why Helen would be a better choice, even though Helen isn’t even running.
It’s such an Emily thing to do. Helen’s getting ready to leave Fletcher’s Grove when she doesn’t really want to, and Emily knows exactly how that feels. She loves it there, too. She just can’t figure out how to stay and do what she thinks she has to do. She really needs to take her own advice.

The whole thing is such a Hallmark moment, and I still can’t believe I’m saying that. No, I’m nowhere near being a #Hallmarkie. I’m just enjoying the Hallmark-liciousness of it all because, seriously, a debate for a volunteer position?
But mostly I’m enjoying the spark between Emily and Sam, and I wish those two would quit holding back and light up like Richard’s ridiculous Christmas display already.
Sam Is So Far Gone
I gave Emily a lump of coal last week for keeping Sam in the dark, and she hasn’t done much to earn her way out of it. But put those two on a murder case together and I forget how mad I am at her for a minute. Sam’s a by-the-book guy, which is why it’s so funny to watch him when Emily warns him he might not like her plan for Albert and Ruth. He’s practically giddy and goes along with her plan despite his better judgment, which doesn’t really exist when Emily is around.
I swear Emily could’ve pushed Richard off the roof herself and Sam would still be talking about their future.

But I don’t think it’s all the Emily love fog, either. She’s good at this. They share what they find, and when she tells him she believes Helen, he takes her seriously. By the time he gets to the roof, Emily’s already figured out Wes killed Richard, and Richard’s Christmas lights have saved her from becoming his next victim. Sam doesn’t even mind that he missed his big rescue. He just looks like he couldn’t be more pleased with her.
Give the woman a badge and let him take her to dinner.
That’s the Sam I wish Emily would think about when she decides he needs protecting. He doesn’t need to be the guy who saves her, and he doesn’t seem particularly worried that she’s better at parts of his job than he is. So why is she so sure he can’t handle the truth about hers?
Tell Him, Emily
I can also see why Aaron is a harder subject than a murder in Fletcher’s Grove. Watching him visit Emily during her CIA training during the flashback, I got the sense he still loved her and she wasn’t entirely over him, either.
Of course she didn’t want to believe he was dangerous. It’s one thing to know the CIA wants you to help bring somebody in. It’s another to hear they think a man you still care about may have been involved in the death of a woman who was helping take down Chimera. I’d have a hard time with that, too.
But Aaron isn’t just an old boyfriend Emily would rather not explain. She’s still a CIA asset, still supposed to help bring him down, and Janet Chase (Olunike Adeliyi) makes it clear she’s being watched.

Janet’s giving her a break to enjoy Christmas with her friends, but she’s keeping a close eye on Emily and wants to know every detail of what Emily’s up to, including what she has planned with Sam. Some break. Sam’s already on her boss’s radar, and he doesn’t even know enough to ask why.
I don’t think Emily came back to Fletcher’s Grove just to open the shop for Christmas. After nearly a year away with her hacker friends, she came back to the town where June and Violet are doing everything they can to get her to stay and where Sam is telling her, flat out, that he thinks they have a future together.
She wants that too, but she still hesitates and it’s maddening. The way Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney play these two, I can see how happy they’d be if Emily would stop treating a life with Sam like something she’s only allowed to want in between assignments.

So tell him, Emily. The whole damn thing. Since when has protocol stopped you before? And who the hell is Sam going to tell? She trusts him enough to work a murder with him. She can trust him enough to let him decide what he’s willing to risk to be with her, especially when he already said he’d do anything to be with her and would follow her anywhere. That’d be enough to convince me.
But Emily still has her obligation to the CIA and she hasn’t quite figured out how to get out of it. Emily had a chance to do something about Aaron when he showed up at her apartment. Instead, she took off, and we still don’t know if she even told Janet he’d been there. After that flashback, I can see why she might not have wanted to.
Helen Has Every Reason to Stay
Wes held a press conference outside the police station after Helen was cleared after being caught inside Albert’s home. It wasn’t as ominous as Wes made it out to be. Albert’s wife gave her a key to feed the fish. The fish are fine, Wes.
I’d also wondered if the Christmas card she sent Wes was a fake, but Helen really did send it. Hearing why she left after Wes’s father died made me feel for both of them, which I didn’t expect given how intent he was on trying to destroy Helen’s life.
Helen had even asked Richard not to leave her anything because she knew what people would say if another husband died. Imagine having to make that request of your husband because people already think they know what kind of woman you are.

I bought Ruth as a suspect once we learned she knew Richard planned to make Helen his sole beneficiary. Helen didn’t even know he was changing the will.
And Albert feuding with Richard over the lights may not have made him a killer, but I’ve seen firsthand how crazy people can get about Christmas displays. Holiday cheer tends to get tossed right into the trash sometimes.
I’m still curious why Mayor Ray was so invested in clearing Helen and I still suspect there might be some romantic interest there on his part though I can admit that maybe I might’ve missed some plausible explanation.
As far as Emily, there’s no mystery at all. Of course she sees herself in a woman who’s about to give up a place she loves because she’s tired of what follows her around.

That’s why I’m glad Helen stays. Does this mean we get to keep the Good Witch for the rest of the season? I hope so. I also like that Helen hires Ruth as her assistant. The will gave them every reason to distrust each other, but now they’ve got a wreath business to run together, and it has nothing to do with who got what from Richard.
I wanted Helen cleared, but I cared more that she got to keep the life she’d made for herself. Now if Emily could only take that leap and realize she deserves the same thing.
🔥 Our Verdict: WATCHABLE
This is the kind of Hallmark-licious episode I can get behind. The Christmas politics are ridiculous, the murder has a satisfying payoff, and Helen’s story is sweet without making light of what she’s been through.
But Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney are why I’d watch these two investigate a missing wreath. They’re fun together, they complement each other in every way, even with investigating murders, and I’m invested enough in seeing them happy that Emily can still drive me nuts.
I’ll take that over a cozy mystery where all I care about is who did it.
Read All of Our Mistletoe Murders Season 3 Coverage
- Mistletoe Murders S3E1: “Don’t Fear the Wreather – Part 1”
- Mistletoe Murders S3E2: “Don’t Fear the Wreather – Part 2”
More Hallmark Coverage:
Keep checking back as we add more Hallmark movies and shows to our watch rotation. Maybe even Hannah Banana
- What if Christmas – Lori Loughlin, Tom Cavanaugh
- Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage
- Garage Sale Mystery – Original 2013 Movie


