For my second Hallmark Countdown to Christmas movie ever, I went with The Nights Before Christmas, starring Hallmark’s resident hunk, Tyler Hynes. I picked it because I love a good time loop. You could tell me somebody’s doing Groundhog Day at a gas station and I’d at least want to see how they get out of it. So sure, let’s do Christmas Eve.

Meanwhile, Hynes celebrated premiere day by posing shirtless in a Santa robe by the pool, which sent the #Hallmarkies swooning. I pictured them floating off like a bunch of Pennywise balloons, except this is Hallmark, so everybody lands in a field of flowers instead of a pile of bones. See? I can do Christmas cheer.

Anyway, I was here for the time loop.

One Christmas Eve Is Plenty

Marty (Hynes) wishes he had more time and gets it in the form of an endlessly repeating Christmas Eve in New York City. He thinks it’s the best thing that’s ever happened to him, at least until he meets Chloe (Laci J Mailey), a newly out-of-work journalist who goes back to not knowing him every time the day resets.

I start twitching when I hear Christmas music over the loudspeaker while I’m still shopping for Halloween candy. I don’t care how good the cookies are. Make me listen to “Jingle Bells” every day, even with Batman smelling in my head, and I’m going to want out. And if you’re telling me I have to sit through the same Christmas Eve dinner with the same relative who can steamroll a perfectly pleasant evening? Sorry, folks. That’s a horror movie.

Still from the Hallmark Movie, The Nights Before Christmas featuring Tyler Hynes as Marty and Laci J Mailey as Chloe.
Photo Credit: Hallmark Media

But I get why Marty likes it. Who hasn’t wanted a little more time to read the books they never get around to or pay attention to the people they normally rush past? Blink and the moment’s gone. Marty gets to linger, and there’s something sweet about how much he enjoys it. I even liked the dive bar opening, with him shooting pool and telling the regulars all about themselves. I’d have a few more questions than they do, but it’s a fun way to show how well he knows this one day.

And yes, that Santa robe is in the movie. He wears a shirt under it. You still have Instagram, #Hallmarkies.

Take Tyler Hynes Out of It for a Second

The movie made me laugh when Marty told his mom she could replace his dad with a cardboard cutout and wouldn’t notice for weeks. I wanted more of that guy. Instead, I got a man who hears what Chloe wants in a boyfriend over breakfast and gets to come back as that guy without her ever remembering she gave him the instructions.

Still from the Hallmark Movie, The Nights Before Christmas featuring Tyler Hynes as Marty and Laci J Mailey as Chloe.
Photo Credit: Hallmark Media

Chloe even jokes that it’s like somebody made Mr. Perfect with a 3D printer. She’s not far off. Marty knows her favorite restaurant, he brings a dog, and I’ll give him credit for actually cooking the dinner after all that practice. But she’s having a first date with a stranger and he’s had who knows how many chances to learn what’ll work on her. I can see why a man who brightens up an especially lousy Christmas Eve would appeal to Chloe. I’m the one who has to sit there knowing how much of it he rehearsed.

The movie comes awfully close to admitting how creepy this is when she gets him thrown in jail. That’s the most believable thing she does. I’d probably call the cops too if a man showed up at my door knowing things about me and explaining it all with a time loop. But when Marty tells her he’d spend a week in jail to be with her, I’m apparently supposed to find that charming. Take Tyler Hynes out of it for a second and tell me that line still works.

Somebody Get Me to Christmas Day

I can go along with Christmas magic. I went along with the alternate timeline in What If Christmas without asking Lori Loughlin or Tom Cavanagh to draw me a diagram. My problem here is how long the movie spends on Marty trying to get the girl when every new attempt makes me want him to get her a little less.

Still from the Hallmark Movie, The Nights Before Christmas featuring Tyler Hynes as Marty and Laci J Mailey as Chloe.
Photo Credit: Hallmark Media

About halfway through, I started skipping ahead to see if I could break my time loop. I landed on a kiss. I couldn’t tell you exactly how they got there, and the fact that I didn’t care enough to go back pretty much tells you where I was with this thing.

Our Verdict: 🗑️ TRASH.

I came for Groundhog Day on Christmas Eve, and for a little while I could see the fun in it. But this thing moves like a River of Molasses, and the more effort Marty put into being Chloe’s dream man, the less I wanted to see him get rewarded for it. A good time-loop movie makes me curious about what’ll be different next time. This one made me reach for the remote.

If you had a blast with it, you don’t have to defend a second of it to me. And I don’t have to pretend I had a good time because Hallmark’s resident hunk looks good in a Santa robe. He does. I still wanted it to be December 25 already.


More Hallmark Coverage

Keep checking back as we add more Hallmark movies and shows to our watch rotation. Maybe even Hannah Banana, one of my faves.


Leave A Reply