I’m not going to give you my list of the scariest movies ever made. For the record, Sinister sits at number one, and Late Night with the Devil isn’t far behind in the department of things that creep me the hell out. Especially that ending. If you’ve ever watched the BBC’s Ghostwatch, you know the kind of unsettling television I’m talking about.

But horror doesn’t have to be a competition to see which movie or show can scare you into sleeping with the lights on. Although if you’ve still got a Clapper lying around, this might be the night to put that sucker to work.

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring Vorelli from Devil Doll.
Photo Credit: Associated Film

So forget the usual parade of horror movie night recommendations. I’ve put together 13 movies and television shows for just about every mood. Some are creepy, some are ridiculous, and a couple might even be safe to watch with the kids.


Don’t Come Home (2024)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring the little girl sitting at the table with a spooky mask on from Don't Come Home on Netflix.
Photo Credit: Netflix

A scary little gem from Netflix, this six-episode Thai horror series wastes no time trying to creep the hell out of you. A mother takes her young daughter to the family’s secluded mansion for a fresh start, only for strange things to begin happening before the girl mysteriously disappears.

Don’t let the subtitles scare you, either. It’s a solid horror story with genuine scares and enough questions to keep you wondering what the hell is going on. So plop down on the couch and pay attention. With the way this one builds its atmosphere of dread, you might be too freaked out to binge all six episodes in one sitting.

Lights on. Take a hint from the little girl in the opening minutes.


The Monster Club (1981)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring Vincent Price on the dance floor with his monsters in The Monster Club.
Photo Credit: ITC

It’s groovy, it’s cheesy as hell, and it has Vincent Price, John Carradine, and Donald Pleasence. What else do you need?

Price plays a vampire who introduces a horror writer to a private nightclub for monsters, where the entertainment includes a live band of humans, an assortment of your favorite classic horror creatures, and three stories about unfortunate encounters with the club’s clientele.

It’s more fun than frightening, with a premise that sounds like somebody combined a horror anthology with a Halloween variety show. Think of it like an amped up The Hilarious House of Frightenstein.

But my favorite part is still Price’s final question, which gives all the rubber masks and silliness something a little more interesting to say about who the real monsters are. And then Vincent Price gets his groove on. Who wouldn’t want to join him?

Depending on your kids’ ages and tolerance for cheesy creatures, this could even be a family Halloween pick. Why shouldn’t the kids have some fun, too?

Lights off. It’s a monster movie. With music. What the hell are you thinking? Just remember to pull out those flashing Halloween lights you’ve got stashed somewhere.


Don’t Pick Up the Phone (2022)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring a man on the payphone from the 2022 Netflix Documentary Don't Pick Up the Phone.
Photo Credit: Netflix

Forget ghosts, demons, and masked killers. Sometimes real people are considerably more disturbing.

This three-part Netflix documentary examines a series of hoax calls to fast-food restaurants across the United States. Someone posing as a police officer persuaded managers to follow increasingly abusive instructions involving their own employees. And the most horrifying part isn’t just what the caller demanded. It’s how many people went along with it without stopping to question what the hell they were doing.

True-crime series come and go, but this is one of those stories that makes you want to check your doors, stop answering your phone, and never speak to a stranger again. What happened to the victims was horrific, and the documentary leaves you thinking about just how easily people can be manipulated by someone claiming to have authority — even if you’re convinced you would’ve responded differently.

Lights on. Leave the phone on do-not-disturb. Trust me, it’s much worse than a scam call about your car’s extended warranty.


Cocaine Crabs From Outer Space (2022)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring a top hat adorned crab from Cocaine Crabs from Outer Space.
Photo Credit: SRS Cinema

You really didn’t think I’d leave a cheesy-ass creature feature off this list, did you? Two extraterrestrial crabs arrive on Earth and encounter a couple of fraternity idiots who apparently think force-feeding alien crustaceans cocaine is a reasonable scientific experiment. Then the crabs develop an appetite for murder, and there you have it.

Forget fancy Hollywood creature effects. We’re talking plastic crabs that look like somebody raided the dollar store. The title should tell you everything you need to know about the kind of movie you’re getting. My favorite part is the crab symphony. It’s ridiculous, it’s hilarious, it pokes fun at itself, and it’s probably even more amusing if you’ve imbibed in something mind-altering, much like the crabs themselves. Who says Halloween has to be serious?

Lights off. Dollar-store plastic looks way more convincing in pitch blackness. Besides, the crabs don’t need to see you laugh at them


As Above, So Below (2014)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring Scarlett in the Paris tunnels with a headlamp on.
Photo Credit: Legendary Pictures

Beneath Paris lies a massive network of catacombs filled with human remains. Apparently, millions of dead people aren’t enough of a warning to stay the hell out. An archaeologist searching for the philosopher’s stone leads an expedition into the underground tunnels, where getting lost turns out to be the least of their problems.

As Above, So Below starts relatively tame, but somewhere around the middle, things take a nasty turn. The hallucinations, disturbing images, and whatever the hell else is happening down there are enough to raise your hackles. Add the claustrophobic setting and found-footage presentation, and you’ve got one of the better examples of a genre that can be pretty hit-or-miss. If enclosed spaces already make you uncomfortable, this one isn’t going to help.

Lights on. Especially if you dislike closed spaces.


Mr. Boogedy (1986)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring a a man in a pilgrim hat with the devil behind him from Mr. Boogedy.
Photo Credit: Walt Disney Television

Who doesn’t want to spend Halloween with a big bag of treats and a ghost named Mr. Boogedy? This 45-minute Disney television movie follows the Davis family as they move into a house in Lucifer Falls and discover they’ve inherited a supernatural resident. It originally aired as part of The Disney Sunday Movie, and it’s exactly the sort of family-friendly haunting that makes a good introduction to Halloween for younger viewers.

There’s a goofy family, an appropriately spooky house, and a few familiar faces: Richard Masur, who played Clark in John Carpenter’s The Thing; John Astin, Gomez from The Addams Family; and even the original Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Kristy Swanson. It’s silly, harmless Halloween fun, and sometimes that’s all you need.

Lights off. Get the Halloween candy and let the kids get spooked by Mr. Boogedy.


Horror in the High Desert 2: Minerva (2023)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring the girl trapped in a car at night on the highway from Horror in the High Desert: Minerva
Photo Credit: Luminol Entertainment

I liked this one more than the original. And considering how creepy the first movie could get, that’s saying something. This found-footage sequel returns to the Nevada wilderness, where a woman’s death and another disappearance suggest that whatever happened to missing outdoorsman Gary Hinge might not be an isolated incident.

The documentary-style presentation builds the mystery, but it’s the atmosphere that makes this one work. That house, the darkness, and a woman running screaming into the woods are the kinds of things that make your spine hurt. And just when you think you’ve settled into the story, something appears where you really wish it hadn’t. There are genuine scares here, not just people wandering around with cameras hoping something will happen.

Lights on. Especially when somebody starts screaming in the woods.


Devil Doll (1964)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring Hugo the dummy from Devil Doll.
Photo Credit: Associated Film

Who cares if it’s black and white? That’s part of what makes this British horror movie so creepy. The Great Vorelli is a stage hypnotist and ventriloquist whose dummy, Hugo, has a very disturbing habit of behaving like something more than a wooden puppet. Vorelli himself looks like the devil, and that doll is scarier than Chucky could ever dream of being. Forget the fancy effects. There’s something genuinely unsettling about a dummy that stares at you as though it knows exactly what you’re thinking. The eerie music just makes it worse.

And have you ever watched a hypnotist on television, with the swinging watch or ticking clock, and wondered whether you might accidentally get hypnotized yourself? They still use those tricks today. What if you’re sitting there watching and suddenly find yourself staring at the screen a little too intently? Yeah. Exactly. Which is why I always look away when those scenes come on. You can laugh all you want.

Lights on. It’s a wooden dummy, FFS. If it looks at you, look back to assert dominance. There’s a reason Vorelli keeps him in a cage


Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy (2025)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring John Wayne Gacy wearing a pirate hat talking to two victims in Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy 2025 (Peacock)
Photo Credit: Peacock

There are approximately a bazillion John Wayne Gacy documentaries floating around, but Peacock’s eight-episode scripted drama is worth watching even if you think you’ve heard everything there is to know about the case. And this isn’t some Ryan Murphy-style attempt to make a serial killer look sympathetic.

Michael Chernus gives a phenomenal performance as Gacy, capturing the disturbing personality behind a man whose crimes were horrific enough without Hollywood trying to glamorize them. The series follows the investigation while also examining the victims, their families, and the failures that allowed Gacy to continue killing. It’s dark, as it should be, and genuinely unsettling even when you already know where the story is going. Of all the Gacy-related shows I’ve watched, this is one of the best, and a perfect pick if you want something real for Halloween.

Lights on. The performances and the story are disturbing enough on their own.


Tales from the Crypt (1989–1996)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring the Cryptkeeper preparing to tell another story in Tales from the Crypt.
Photo Credit: HBO

What Halloween is complete without our favorite Cryptkeeper? HBO’s legendary horror anthology delivered gruesome morality tales, twisted humor, plenty of guest stars, and enough terrible puns to make you groan. But I’ll tell you something: the Cryptkeeper himself is the reason I keep coming back.

I’ve always wondered why Tales from the Crypt opened with “The Man Who Was Death,” about an executioner who decides to take justice into his own hands, instead of “And All Through the House”. A woman murders her husband on Christmas Eve, and then a homicidal maniac dressed as Santa Claus shows up. Now THAT would’ve been one hell of an introduction to the Cryptkeeper.

There are plenty of standout episodes across seven seasons, but for me, the real star will always be that cackling corpse introducing the mayhem and cracking jokes afterward. The stories are practically window dressing; he’s the one who makes the whole thing so much fun. And since the episodes are short, you can watch one or let the Cryptkeeper entertain you all night.

Lights off. You can’t properly enjoy the Cryptkeeper with the lights on.


The Thing (2011 and 1982)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring an alien head from 1982 The Thing.
Photo Credit: Universal Pictures

Why watch one movie about a shape-shifting alien terrorizing researchers in Antarctica when you can watch two? And that’s exactly what I do. Every time.

Start with 2011’s The Thing, where a Norwegian research team discovers something ancient buried beneath the ice. Then go straight into John Carpenter’s 1982 classic, where Kurt Russell and his fellow Americans discover that their neighbors had a considerably worse experience than anyone realized.

The 2011 film is a prequel, despite arriving nearly thirty years after Carpenter’s version. And while the 1982 movie is an undeniable classic, I’ve always had a particular soft spot for the newer one. CGI or not, I love it. Although I would’ve liked to see the practical creature effects before so much of that work was replaced digitally.

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring Kate and Carter in a burning hallway in The Thing 2011.
Photo Credit: Universal Pictures

There are discrepancies between the films, including equipment that looks a little too modern, but the prequel does something clever with the importance of earrings when determining who might be the alien. Which brings me to the eternal question: who the hell is the Thing at the end of Carpenter’s movie? I’ve always suspected MacReady. Some argue Childs isn’t wearing his earring, but I can see it.

These are two movies I watch constantly, sometimes just as background while I’m working. They’re right up there with Columbo, Scooby-Doo, and the Garage Sale Mysteries. Don’t judge me for putting Hallmark on that list. And if you love both movies, I’d recommend owning them so you can play them back-to-back without chasing them across streaming services.

Lights off. Antarctica looks better in the dark. Just don’t trust anybody.


Parents (1988)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring a pair of medical scissors stuck in a apiece of meat from Parents.
Photo Credit: Vestron Pictures

Let’s eat! Poor kid.

Parents takes us back to a picture-perfect 1950s American household, where ten-year-old Michael begins suspecting that his mother and father have some rather disturbing ideas about what’s for dinner. Randy Quaid and Mary Beth Hurt play the parents, whose seemingly respectable lives conceal something far nastier than an ordinary family secret. Mom ranks right up there with the creepiest movie mothers, and Dad is just… a nightmare.

This isn’t gruesome horror from beginning to end. It’s a slower, strangely subdued, underrated movie, with black comedy, unsettling dreams, and just enough blood to remind you what kind of film you’re watching. And despite the uncomfortable atmosphere and increasingly suspicious dinner arrangements, it’s one of those movies you might find yourself watching more than once.

Lights off. With a bowl of popcorn — and no meat!


Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark (1973)

13 Things to Watch (Lights On or Off) Halloween featuring the goblins from Don't Be Afraid of the Dark 1973
Photo Credit: ABC

When a movie opens with a black cat staring at you and barely audible whispering, you already know you’re in trouble. This 1973 television horror movie follows Sally Farnham, who moves into an old mansion with her husband and makes the spectacularly bad decision to open a sealed fireplace. Of course, it releases a bunch of sinister little creatures that would very much like Sally to join them. And, of course, nobody believes her.

What makes this one so creepy isn’t simply the creatures themselves. It’s the whispering. That horrible, almost unintelligible sound that makes you wonder whether you actually heard something or imagined it. Then you start seeing what those little goblin-devil things look like, and suddenly the whispers are the least of your problems.

Considering this was made for television in 1973, it’s surprisingly effective. And it reminded me of Mattel’s old Baby Secret whispering doll. Because apparently whispering toys weren’t disturbing enough on their own. There’s also a lesson here: if somebody tells you to leave a sealed fireplace alone, LISTEN. And that sinister ending? Mission accomplished.

Forget the 2011 remake for a minute. Seek out the original.

Lights on. Are you crazy? Don’t be afraid of the dark? No. Be very afraid of the dark.


So, Are You Keeping the Lights On?

There you have it. Thirteen ways to have a good time with horror movies and tv, whether you watch with the lights off or with every lamp in the house blazing like a Christmas tree. As long as you’re having fun, that’s all that matters.

Just remember, if you hear something whispering from the other room, don’t investigate. Don’t open any mysterious fireplaces, and for the love of God, don’t bring home a ventriloquist dummy.

And if you’re still awake at three in the morning wondering whether that noise came from the television or somewhere behind you?

Sleep tight.


Leave A Reply